Nina Allen Freeman » Blog
The Black Dog of the Inner Critic
Posted on 5/29/2012 7:04:40 AM
By Nina Allen Freeman
Comment on this
Topics: Advice for Artists
"Jetty Point" acrylic on paper by Nina Allen Freeman
You know the Black Dog ; the one that says in your ear, "Who do you think you are?" "You can't Paint!" "What were you thinking, trying to do that!" "You should just give this up." That Black Dog has followed me around for many years now nipping at my heels and busy barking at other artists too. He is the voice of all the negative things heard and imagined about following a creative life. We've all heard them; you can't do that - you will starve, you are not good enough, you should get a real job, artists go crazy. Also known as the inner critic and not the same as taking a positive critical look at our work. The inner critic allows negative, destructive thoughts interfere with the artists' ability to work.
Some artists, blessed with remarkable talent, have been completely frozen by the Black Dog and unable to paint for years. Others have a milder form but also damaging and say negative things about their own abilities, refuse to show their work because "I'm not good enough", or severely under price their works. Some artists struggle to work and have periods of productivity with gaps in which they are unable to work. I believe all artists have experienced some form of the inner critic interfering in their lives, even though it may not interrupt their work.
Getting rid of the Black Dog is not easy and is a matter of making some new routines and not letting the negativity take over. There are some great books available. Two of my favorites are; Art & Fear - Observations On The Perils (and Rewards) of Artmaking by David Bayles & Ted Orland, and The Artist's Way - A Spiritual Path to Higher Creativity by Julia Cameron. Some suggestions for keeping the inner critic at bay are below.
- If you work alone and do not belong to an art group; I recommend you look around and find a local group to join. Art associations can offer networking, friendships with other artists, critique opportunities and most of all the knowledge that you are not alone.
- The Black Dog of the inner critic is all about thinking. Your negative thoughts are interfering with your work life-so change your thoughts. Remember the positive things that friends or acquaintances have said about your paintings or your work; write them down if you need to. If you are remembering some second grade teacher who said you will never be an artist; forget that. Every time the negative thoughts come to you, substitute with the positive ones. If you do this consistently, it will become a habit in time.
- Try getting away from your usual working routine. If you are a studio painter, try plein air painting. If you are a plein air painter, try the studio. Switch to a different media for a while. Go on a photography or sketching trip. While doing these things, erase from your mind any thoughts of your usual work, consider it like a vacation. Return to your usual work when you are ready.
- Many artists keep sketchbooks and others think of this as too structured an activity and don't want to do it. Artists in general are visual people, we respond to things visually and remember things visually. I remember places I have sketched more than ones I have just visited. Keep a sketchbook or journal for things you want to remember. Write in positive comments people make about your work, techniques you learn that work for you, interesting designs you want to remember, color combinations you want to refer to later, things you are thinking or feeling while you are painting.
Art making is about your life and saying what you need to say. The inner critic effectively silences the artist. Don't let it silence you. Maybe in time the Black Dog will become a big lovable Labrador and will stay out of your studio.
I welcome your comments on my Blog posts and look forward to them. If you have questions about painting methods or anything I have mentioned, I will respond to them via email as soon as I am able to. Keep painting! Nina Freeman
Leave a Comment